Playoff History of Youngstown State Penguins
| 12/03/16 | Jacksonville State | 40 | 24 | | Won | +5.5 W | 44 O | @ Jacksonville, AL |
| 12/10/16 | Wofford | 23 | 30 | (ot) | Won | -6.5 W | 41.5 O | @ Youngstown, OH |
| 12/17/16 | Eastern Washington | 40 | 38 | | Won | +13 W | 57 O | @ Cheney, WA |
| 01/07/17 | James Madison | 14 | 28 | | Lost | +8 L | 63.5 U | @ Frisco, TX |
| 03/06/21 | Southern Illinois | 30 | 22 | | Lost | | | @ Youngstown, OH |
| 03/13/21 | South Dakota State | 17 | 19 | | Lost | | | @ Brookings, SD |
| 03/20/21 | South Dakota | 10 | 28 | | Won | | | @ Youngstown, OH |
| 04/03/21 | Western Illinois | 24 | 27 | | Lost | | | @ Macomb, IL |
| 04/10/21 | Missouri State | 10 | 21 | | Lost | | | @ Springfield, MO |
| 12/02/23 | Villanova | 28 | 45 | | Lost | +6 L | 57.5 O | @ Villanova, PA |
| totals | | 4-6 | (3-2) | |