Playoff History of San Diego Toreros
| 12/01/12 | Marist | 34 | 10 | | Won | | | @ Poughkeepsie, NY |
| 11/29/14 | Montana | 14 | 52 | | Lost | | | @ Missoula, MN |
| 12/03/16 | North Dakota State | 7 | 45 | | Lost | +25.5 L | 47 O | @ Fargo, ND |
| 12/02/17 | North Dakota State | 3 | 38 | | Lost | +26.5 L | 51 U | @ Fargo, ND |
| 11/30/19 | Northern Iowa | 3 | 17 | | Lost | +14 T | | @ Cedar Falls, IA |
| 03/13/21 | Drake | 13 | 10 | | Won | | | @ Des Moines, IA |
| 03/20/21 | Butler | 13 | 27 | | Won | | | @ San Diego, CA |
| 03/27/21 | Presbyterian College | 24 | 21 | | Won | | | @ Clinton, SC |
| 04/03/21 | Davidson | 31 | 25 | | Lost | | | @ San Diego, CA |
| 04/10/21 | Stetson | 10 | 34 | | Won | | | @ San Diego, CA |
| 04/17/21 | Valparaiso | 19 | 20 | | Lost | | | @ Valparaiso, IN |
| totals | | 5-6 | (0-2-1) | |