Playoff History of Illinois State Redbirds
| 12/01/12 | Appalachian State | 38 | 37 | (ot) | Won | | | @ Boone, NC |
| 12/08/12 | Eastern Washington | 35 | 51 | | Lost | | | @ Cheney, WA |
| 12/06/14 | Northern Iowa | 21 | 41 | | Won | | | @ Normal, IL |
| 12/13/14 | Eastern Washington | 59 | 46 | | Won | | | @ Cheney, WA |
| 12/20/14 | New Hampshire | 21 | 18 | | Won | | | @ Durham, NH |
| 01/10/15 | North Dakota State | 29 | 27 | | Lost | | | @ Frisco, TX |
| 12/05/15 | Western Illinois | 19 | 36 | | Won | | | @ Normal, IL |
| 12/11/15 | Richmond | 39 | 27 | | Lost | | | @ Normal, IL |
| 11/30/19 | Southeast Missouri State | 24 | 6 | | Won | +2.5 W | | @ Cape Girardeau, MO |
| 12/07/19 | Central Arkansas | 24 | 14 | | Won | -1 W | 43.5 U | @ Conway, AR |
| 12/14/19 | North Dakota State | 3 | 9 | | Lost | +24.5 W | 44 U | @ Fargo, ND |
| 03/06/21 | Northern Iowa | 10 | 20 | | Lost | | | @ Cedar Falls, IA |
| 03/13/21 | North Dakota State | 13 | 21 | | Lost | | | @ Fargo, ND |
| 03/20/21 | Western Illinois | 18 | 26 | | Won | | | @ Normal, IL |
| totals | | 8-6 | (3-0) | |